How to use best-worst scaling to make better decisions

Use best-worst scaling, or MaxDiff analysis, to learn what’s important to your customers.

Best-worst scaling, also known as MaxDiff (maximum difference) analysis, is useful when gauging preferences on messaging, brand names, product features, and more. It’s easy to use and offers clear insights into what customers truly like—and dislike. Let’s take a look at best-worst scaling and how you can use it to make better decisions for your business.

What is best-worst scaling (MaxDiff analysis)?

Best-worst scaling is a type of survey research conducted to understand the relative importance of attributes such as product features, packaging, messaging, etc., to your target market. By identifying what consumers really want most, you can maximize your business investments of time and capital on efforts that will appeal to your target market.

Best-worst scaling asks respondents to choose among several options at once—selecting only the best and worst options. This type of survey question allows you to collect the information you are seeking quickly and definitively. There’s no guesswork about what respondents mean when they choose a score near the middle of the range as in Likert scales or rating scale questions. Your respondents simply choose the most and least important options to them. MaxDiff questions can be asked in a single survey or as part of a longer questionnaire.

Two terms are frequently used in best-worst scaling:

  1. Attribute: a single property, item, or feature for measurement
  2. Set: a group of attributes displayed to participants

How to conduct your best-worst scaling study: 

  1. Once you’ve determined the attributes you’re testing, you’ll generate your experimental design
  2. Create multiple versions (usually 6 or more) of best-worst scaling questions to test your chosen attributes, creating sets using randomization, item balance, paired balance, or connectivity.
    1. Each attribute should appear at least three times
    2. Each attribute should appear the same number of times
    3. Each attribute should appear with the other attributes the same number of times (e.g. each attribute appears with each other attribute twice)
  3. Distribute your survey to your target market using SurveyMonkey Audience or your own contact list. 
  4. Collect and analyze results. 
  5. Present your findings to stakeholders with key findings and recommendations.

Best-worst scaling is very similar to conjoint analysis for determining respondents’ preferences for various items or features. However, MaxDiff analysis is easier to use and less refined than conjoint analysis. 

Here are examples of the two methods for comparison:

Conjoint analysis studies mimic shopping trips, where participants review products, features, attributes, and prices to make purchase decisions. The analysis is complex and considers multiple factors.

For example, you could ask “If you were in the market for a new smartphone, which of the following would be most appealing to you?” Respondents would compare brand, price, storage and more. 

In best-worst scale survey questions, respondents are asked to choose the least and most important factors within the answer options. Data analysis is faster and cleaner.

For example, you could ask, “If you were in the market for a new smartphone, please indicate the feature that would be the most important in your purchase decision and which feature would be the least important.” You would then list various features like camera, display, face ID, and more–and respondents would decide which feature was most and least important. 

Most ImportantLeast Important
◻️Selfie camera◻️
◻️Oversize display◻️
◻️Stereo sound◻️
◻️Face ID◻️
◻️Battery life◻️
◻️Multiple color options◻️
◻️Price◻️

As you can see in the examples, both methods are seeking what customers prioritize when purchasing a smartphone. The best-worst model data will reveal the most preferred feature and the least preferred feature. Conjoint analysis shows how much each feature influences the final purchasing decision. 

Often, these methods are used together to create a more detailed picture of what customers want and are willing to pay for.

Advantages of best-worst scaling

In addition to the ease of creation and data analysis, best-worst scaling has several advantages.

Easy for respondents

Best-worst scaling questions are easy for respondents to answer. They are, in effect, simulating real-world behaviors in making choices and trade-offs, eliminating options that they don’t feel strongly about. Answering several of these questions makes the strength and importance of each choice known.

Eliminates bias

By forgoing a ranking scale, best-worst scaling avoids biases from cultural differences—some cultures have associations with different numbers—or perceptions of ratings. Respondents may also have list order bias, where they indicate that all features are equally important. When bias occurs, the business may waste resources on improvements or features that aren’t truly important to customers.

Allows for statistical modeling

MaxDiff survey data is well suited for creating statistical models. These models make it possible to quantify preferences and understand what your target market values.

Customer satisfaction

Determining what features are deemed best and worst by your customers provides you with actionable insights for product features and improvements, new products, and obsolete product features. Use this data to give your customers what they truly want and value. This will result in increased customer satisfaction overall.

Limitations of best-worst scaling

As with any process, there are some downsides to best-worst scaling.

Survey length

Depending upon the number of attributes you are testing, it may take more time to take your survey. Shorter surveys tend to have higher response rates. 

Result interpretation

MaxDiff analyses measure respondents’ preferences based on the attributes presented in relation to each other. This does not account for whether the attributes offered on the survey are good or bad based on an absolute perspective.

Does not optimize for holistic product

Best-worst scaling is typically used to optimize features, not the product as a whole. For example, your MaxDiff survey may show a definite preference for one feature, but in reality, customers may not be willing to pay a higher price for the feature. To dig deeper into your results, perform a conjoint analysis to test the product as a whole.

Context effect

Is the level of preference indicated for an attribute conditional upon the alternatives it is compared to? This is the context effect. For example, if you’re conducting a best-worst scaling smartphone study and your attributes are Samsung, Nokia, Google, Sony, and Apple, respondents are probably thinking about Google in terms of hardware. But if you’re doing a study that includes Google and Yahoo in its attributes, people will more likely think of Google in terms of its search engine.

It’s important to be aware of the context effect even though it is impractical to try to avoid attributes because of this possibility.

Best-worst scales vs. standard rating scales

Standard rating questions can have user scale bias, scale meaning bias, and lack of discrimination between answer choices. MaxDiff surveys eliminate the issue of bias because participants are asked to choose their preference, not rank or rate.

As we mentioned in our earlier description, best-worst scaling is closely related to conjoint analysis. Conjoint analysis is used to determine how different features would affect a purchase decision, while MaxDiff asks what features are most important to them. For a clear picture of customer overall preference, use best-worst and conjoint analysis together to combine and compare the results.

When to use best-worst scaling

There are many uses for best-worst scaling. Primarily, it is used to identify preferences among a list of attributes in a set. It’s a fast and easy way to obtain important information, especially if you have a small marketing budget. Best-worst scaling is a very effective method for determining what your target market really wants.

New product feature prioritization

Best-worst scaling surveys are valuable tools in product development of upgrades. If your product sales are flagging and you’ve decided you need to update the product, a MaxDiff survey can help. Rather than deciding internally what features you think your customers want, present your features (attributes) in sets and find out what is truly important to them.

Name testing

Is the name you’re considering for your product appealing to your target market? Perform best-worst scaling and analysis to obtain information about which names are preferred by customers.

Brand fit

To take name testing further, use best-worst scaling to find out how the names you’re considering for your new product fit with your target market’s perception of your brand. 

Others

MaxDiff surveys can be used for multiple purposes, including:

  • How customers prioritize functionality: prioritize investment in features that respondents have reported are most important to them
  • Customer focus when buying: determine what particular types of attributes score higher than others
  • How messaging resonates with customers: choose your marketing and advertising messages based on respondents’ preferences
  • Brand comparisons: how do respondents feel about your brand in comparison to your competitors?
  • Identifying preferences and patterns across customer segments: use the segmentation and preference data to customize your messaging
  • Testing how new product ideas are received: before you begin product testing, find out what your customers are looking for—what problem they need you to help solve
  • Identifying areas/aspects that produce strong emotions: find out if your customers feel strongly about certain attributes and respond to them emotionally

Examples of best-worst scaling

Now that we’ve covered why you should use best-worst scaling, let’s look at some examples.

Example 1

Question 1:

Think about what would make you choose one restaurant over another. Considering these features, which is most important and which is least important? 

Most ImportantLeast Important
◻️Uses only locally-grown ingredients◻️
◻️Restaurant supports charities◻️
◻️Options for special diets (e.g. vegan, gluten-free)◻️
◻️Fun, clean atmosphere◻️

Question 2:

Think about what would make you choose one restaurant over another. Considering these features, which is most important and which is least important?

Most ImportantLeast Important
◻️Serves alcoholic beverages◻️
◻️Restaurant supports charities◻️
◻️Totally organic menu◻️
◻️Uses only locally-grown ingredients◻️

Example 2

Question 1:

When choosing a hotel, what are the most and least important factors in your decision?

Most ImportantLeast Important
◻️Workout facilities◻️
◻️Restaurant on-site◻️
◻️Pool◻️
◻️Suites available◻️

Question 2:

When choosing a hotel, what are the most and least important factors in your decision?

Most ImportantLeast Important
◻️Cleanliness◻️
◻️Free Wi-Fi◻️
◻️Complimentary breakfast◻️
◻️Suites available◻️

Example 3

Question 1:

Below are names for our new line of cookware for kids. Please indicate the name you think is the best fit for our brand and which is the worst.

Best fitWorst fit
◻️Kids Cook◻️
◻️The Mini Mix◻️
◻️Kids in the Kitchen◻️
◻️Super Cooks!◻️

Question 2:

Below are names for our new line of cookware for kids. Please indicate the name you think is the best fit for our brand and which is the worst

Best fitWorst fit
◻️Kids in the Kitchen◻️
◻️Salt and Pepper Cookware◻️
◻️Kids Kuisine◻️
◻️We Can Cook!◻️

Helpful tips:

  • Ensure that your survey is mobile-friendly. Respondents may use their smartphones to take your MaxDiff analysis. Use legible fonts and short text so there are no problems interpreting the questions.
  • Use images as attributes or add images as needed to enhance your survey. Images should be of good quality and compressed for fast loading.
  • Remember that conjoint analysis is needed to compare products as a whole.
  • Use clear descriptions where needed. Participants must easily understand the attributes.
  • Avoid offering too many attributes.
  • During analysis, take into account the time spent answering questions. If the response was entered in two seconds, it may not have been given proper consideration.

How to use the data gathered from best-worst scaling

Once you’ve gathered your best-worst scaling data, you need to analyze it before putting it to use.

There are four main types of analysis for MaxDiff:

  1. Counting analysis: this is the easiest way to obtain basic results. Use this formula to calculate scores:

# of times attribute was selected as best - # of times attribute was selected as worst
# of times the item appeared

  • Attributes with higher scores are more appealing to your target audience. 
  • Attributes with a score of zero were chosen as most appealing and least appealing equally.
  • A positive score means the attribute was chosen as most appealing more often than least appealing.
  • A negative score means the attribute was chosen as least appealing more often than most appealing.
  1. Individual-level score estimation: this type of analysis uses the counting analysis results to run a regression analysis. This analysis will yield more nuanced responses.
  2. Aggregate score estimation: if you have the time and resources, you can use a tool to identify which items are most important without considering individual-level responses.
  3. Latent class estimation: this analysis provides richer segmentation of respondents for finding trends that may not be easily identified.

Data may be presented to your team, management, or other stakeholders in bar graphs, pie charts, or other visualizations that make the information easily digestible. 

With the data from your best-worst scaling in hand, you can make decisions on everything from prioritizing improvements to choosing a product name. Because your decisions are based on data from your target market, you can avoid making choices that will fall flat. This will ultimately yield better responses to your decisions. 

For example, if your study revealed that an air fryer was the feature customers most wanted you to add to your current toaster oven and you acted upon that data, you would see an increase in sales of your new model with the air fryer.

Start using best-worst scaling in your business

Use best-worst scaling to determine what your target market prefers in names, packaging, product features, improvements, and more. And make informed decisions that your customers will love.

For more information on MaxDiff surveys, visit Momentive, maker of SurveyMonkey. While you’re there, check out the other AI-driven market research solutions from Momentive.

Get started with your market research

Global survey panel

Collect market research data by sending your survey to a representative sample

Research services

Get help with your market research project by working with our expert research team

Expert solutions

Test creative or product concepts using an automated approach to analysis and reporting

To read more market research resources, visit our Sitemap.